In Defense of Nature: Why Barred Owls Should Not Be Killed to “Save” Spotted Owls

November 2024

 

If you google “Barred Owl Spotted Owl issue” or similar terms, you will find numerous articles containing links to studies that support the controversial current plan by the US Fish & Wildlife Service (FWS) for lethal removal of nearly a half million Barred Owls1 over the next 30 years, in an effort to preserve Northern and California Spotted Owls2 in Washington, Oregon and California. The plan involves agency staff or trained contractors using a recording of the Barred Owls’ call to lure them in, and then shooting them with shotguns.

 

The purpose of this article is to provide a summary of the issues leading to the proposal, a recap of the conclusions reached by research studies to date, and to lay out the reasons All About Owls believes that more work needs to be done before enacting the plan which is set to go into effect as early as spring of 20253.

 

The Problem, in a Nutshell

 

Barred Owls and Spotted Owls, which are congeneric (related) species, are likely to have diverged from a common ancestor around seven million years ago. Spotted Owls are native to western North America. One of the three subspecies, Northern Spotted Owls, can be found from southwestern British Columbia through Washington and Oregon, and into northern California. They are non-migratory, and their preferred habitat is the canopy of old-growth forests, which can take from 150 to 200 years to mature. It is estimated that suitable Spotted Owl habitat has been reduced by over 60% in the last 190 years.

 

Beginning in the mid-80’s, studies found that Spotted Owl populations were decreasing due to logging of old growth forest in Canada, Washington and Oregon. This led to an acrimonious battle between logging companies and environmental/wildlife organizations, which peaked with the Spotted Owl becoming listed as Threatened under the Endangered Species Act in 1990. Climate change, population growth and increased wildfires are additional factors that have added to owl habitat destruction.

Spotted Owl, photo by step2626 on iStock
Spotted Owl, photo by step2626 on iStock

In addition to habitat destruction, pesticides and rodenticides, one of the more recent threats cited by researchers and the Fish & Wildlife Service with respect to the Spotted Owl population decline is the proliferation of Barred Owls in the Pacific Northwest, where they have been labeled as “invasive.” The invasive species label has been rationalized due to the Barred Owls’ classification as non-native in that area and their impact on Spotted Owls. This designation is then provided as justification for the current plan to kill them in large numbers.

 

Contrary to this logic, recent genome studies actually indicate that western Barred Owls are genetically diverged from eastern Barred Owls with a significant number of private variants, suggesting that this divergence occurred thousands of years ago. Observational data records eastern Barred Owls as steadily moving from the east coast northward and westward since the early 1900s, seemingly driven by the arrival of European settlers and the opportunity provided by human-induced changes in the Great Plains and in the boreal forests of the Northwest – specifically, the planting of trees in the former and fire suppression in the latter.

 

Barred Owls were first documented in British Columbia in 1943 and first recorded in eastern Washington state in 1965. It was in the 1980s that Barred Owls came to be considered as established in the Pacific Northwest, and they have been gradually expanding their range south since that time. However, the approximate 130-year timeline implied by this observational data for the eastern Barred Owl/western Barred Owl divergence is soundly refuted by the recent research, and there is genomic evidence which supports the theory that western Barred Owls lived in the Pacific Northwest thousands of years ago.

Barred Owl, photo by 2H Media on Unsplash
Barred Owl, photo by 2H Media on Unsplash

Like the Spotted Owl, Barred Owls are an indicator species for the management of old-growth forests. They are nonmigratory birds originally native to eastern North America, primarily inhabiting mature, undisturbed forests with a mix of conifers and hardwoods, often near water. They are sympatric (occur in the same geographical area) with the Spotted Owl and generally outcompete them because they are larger in size, more aggressive, and less discerning about their diet. Numerous studies conclude that their presence in Spotted Owl territories has led to the alarming decline of Spotted Owl populations over the last two decades. The impact has been greatest on Northern Spotted Owls in the Pacific Northwest, and more recently on California Spotted Owls.

 

The final Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) issued by the FWS outlines 6 options that were considered: One that involves taking no action, and 5 others that each include some portion that recommends killing Barred Owls.

While Barred Owls are not considered to be native in the western states, their migration is a natural expansion precipitated primarily by human intervention in the form of environment alteration. This is is one of the points on which we take exception to the current plan to kill them in large numbers.

Pilot Studies

As part of experimental programs conducted over the last decade in the northwest, approximately 3000 Barred Owls were killed with the oversight of the Fish & Wildlife Service. While researchers conclude that this action has contributed to potential stabilization of Spotted Owl populations in specific locales, there has so far been no definitive evidence of a significant population increase or return to earlier numbers.

 

A study published in 2019 by Wiens et al. states that the removal of Barred Owls in specific regions resulted in a 0.2% decline in Spotted Owls, whereas areas with no removal saw a 12% decline in Spotted Owls. The researchers’ conclusion is part of the logic used by the US Fish & Wildlife Service to justify the much larger plan to destroy hundreds of thousands of Barred Owls over 30 years.

 

In a Review of the Effects of Barred Owls on Spotted Owls, the authors posit nine “hypothetical futures,” one of which states “quality habitat may buffer Spotted Owls from the negative influences of Barred Owls.” A 2016 study cited in the review also states that while Barred Owl influx had a negative impact, “…the amount of suitable owl habitat, local weather, and regional climatic patterns also were related to survival, occupancy (via colonization rate), recruitment, and, to a lesser extent, fecundity…” This demonstrates that the removal of Barred Owls does not guarantee the restoration of Spotted Owls to their previous numbers.

 

Some researchers have also pointed out that because of Barred Owl adaptability and ongoing expansion in the west, once the mass killing is instituted, it will need to continue indefinitely, or the Barred Owls will continue to push out Spotted Owls.

 

Adaptation: Nature’s Strategy Supports Barred Owl Survival

 

One way to look at the situation is to question why such a long-term, costly and ethically problematic plan should be implemented to conserve Spotted Owls. The case could be made that there is a sense of sentimentality toward the Spotted Owl over the Barred Owl. If we start from a place of respect for nature’s process, the migration of the Barred Owls into Spotted Owl territory can be seen as a natural reponse to human activity that has caused climate and habitat change. Such range expansion by a species in response to ecosystem changes is a natural evolutionary course that is as old as the earth itself. The argument can then be made that Barred Owls are simply taking their destined place in nature’s process and have a legitimate claim to territory, be it part of an historic legacy or discovered through a migration borne from environmental pressure or opportunity.

 

Hybridization between barred and Spotted Owls has been observed in recent years, with the moniker Sparred Owl given to the resulting bird. The birds exhibit characteristics of both subspecies, including both barring and spots on the breast plumage. Although current sightings have resulted in small numbers, the hybridization has been successful. It may be evidence of nature’s adaptation to a changing ecosystem. The FWS strategy notes that hybrids may also be included in the culling (Section A2.3.3, Lethal Removal of Hybrids), but the content alludes to the real potential that exists for Spotted Owls to be killed “accidentally” due to the complexity of identifying the hybrids.

 

A closer reading of additional studies and a look at ethical questions raised by killing Barred Owls shows that while FWS conducted an ethical review facilitated by wildlife ethicist Bill Lynn for initial studies with culling on a smaller scale, the organization did not bring that same rigor to the large plan proposed to roll out in 2025. “We have a virtually unlimited amount of harm being delivered to Barred Owls, for very little result,” Lynn said, pointing out that Barred Owls would only be killed in up to a third of the northern Spotted Owl’s range. Wayne Pacelle, founder of Animal Wellness Action and president of the Center for a Humane Economy, has characterized the FWS plan as “the agency stepping onto a killing treadmill that it can never dismount.”

 

Eric Forsman, a U.S. Forest Service wildlife biologist and Spotted Owl researcher, says, “I think in the long run we simply can’t control Barred Owl populations on a large scale. It would be incredibly expensive and essentially, you’d have to do it forever.”

 

The case can be made that victimizing animals for adapting to ecosystem degradation is not sustainable and, while the presence of Barred Owls is an added stressor to Spotted Owl populations, the primordial issue in the century-long Spotted Owl decline is habitat loss.

 

“We don’t think it’s ethical to be going out and calling for Barred Owls and shooting them with a shotgun because they are currently doing better in the existing environment and outcompeting other species,” says Jennifer Best, wildlife law program director for the Connecticut-based animal advocacy group Friends of Animals, to NBC News’ Evan Bush. She added, “I think protecting old-growth forests in areas where Spotted Owls do live and can live is the most important thing — and working to restore habitat that has been destroyed. It’s not an easy or quick fix, but that’s the potential long-term solution.”

 

Hilary Franz, the Commissioner of Public Lands for Washington State, questions the viability and ethics of the program in a YouTube video, which she shared with US Secretary of the Interior, Deb Haaland. She asks how FWS can guarantee that only Barred Owls will be targeted, and whether the expenditure of hundreds of millions of dollars can be justified with many other species being threatened.

 

A Call for Further Research and Additional Ethical Review

 

Wildlife ethicist Bill Lynn sums up the dilemma by saying, “This is the question of tragedy, moral injury, moral grief…There are times when you can’t save the patient, or when doing so will do such grievous harm that on balance, you don’t…That applies to Barred and Spotted Owls as well. Where is the endpoint? Is it an unlimited killing?”

 

While the Endangered Species Act rightly requires that we take action in response to the Spotted Owl decline, we need to be sure that we aren’t failing to see the forest for the trees by adopting a plan that is fundamentally a diversion from the need to address the deep-rooted, historic threats to the Spotted Owl populations.

 

No matter which side of the debate you look at, killing one type of bird in an effort to save another, especially by following the protocol laid out in the current Fish & Wildlife Service plan, is a slippery slope that should not be embarked upon until further exploration of alternative, more strategic solutions and a renewed ethical review have been conducted. Biology doesn’t support it, history doesn’t support it, common sense doesn’t support it – and certainly the science of morality doesn’t support it. Cautious consideration is warranted before the FWS starts to head down a road of managing natural interactions between wildlife species.

 

As the noted physician, biologist, researcher and author Lewis Thomas states: “When you are confronted by any complex social system…with things about it that you’re dissatisfied with and anxious to fix, you cannot just step in and set about fixing with much hope of helping…You cannot meddle with one part of a complex system from the outside, without the almost certain risk of setting off disastrous events that you hadn’t counted on in other, remote parts. If you want to fix something, you are first obligated to understand the whole system.” – Lewis Thomas, The Medusa and the Snail: More Notes of a Biology Watcher (NewYork, NY: Viking Press, 1979).

 

FOOTNOTES

 

 1 Barred Owls are large, stocky owls with rounded heads, no ear tufts, and rounded tails. They are mottled brown and white overall, with dark brown, almost black, eyes. The underparts are mostly marked with vertical brown bars on a white background, while the upper breast is crossed with horizontal brown bars. They are smaller than Great Horned Owls and larger than Barn Owls. Barred Owls have a widely varied diet, including small mammals, such as squirrels, rabbits, oppossums, shrews, as well as birds, reptiles, insects and occasionally aquatic wildlife.  They have a distinctive call that is characterized as “Who cooks for you?” (video recording)

2 Spotted Owls have three identified subspecies: The Northern Spotted Owl lives from northern California to British Columbia, and is the darkest brown with the smallest white spots. The California Spotted Owl lives only in California, is lighter brown and has larger spots. The Mexican Spotted Owl is the smallest and lightest with the largest white spots. Its range goes from Utah and Colorado southward into southern Mexico. The most important food for the Spotted Owl are flying squirrels and woodrats. In areas where woodrats make up the bulk of their diet, the owl has a smaller home range. The Spotted Owl also eats bats and other owls. Click here for a recording of a Northern Spotted Owl call.

3 If the FWS culling strategy goes into effect beginning in Spring 2025, it will potentially be disruptive to Spotted Owl reproduction, as the typical breeding season is March through August.

4 Hybrid, aka Sparred Owls, display a combination of features from both parent species, including larger eyes, a barred owl-like tail, and a spotted owl-like breast. They are larger sized like the Barred Owl, with the Spotted Owl’s darker coloring. Their breast feathers are a mix of spots and bars, similar to a checkerboard pattern. Their call is also representative of both species: a series of staccato "hoos" like a spotted owl, followed by a "hoo-ah" like a barred owl. 

 

RESOURCES

 

Proposed Barred Owl Management Strategy

US Fish and Wildlife Service Proposal

 

Washington State Commissioner of Public Lands statement (video)

Hilary Franz, Washington State Commissioner of Public Lands

 

The effects of habitat, climate, and Barred Owls on long-term demography of Northern Spotted Owls

Katie M. Dugger et al., The Condor, Volume 118, Issue 1, 1 February 2016, December 10, 2015

 

Researchers Question Spotted Owl Recovery Efforts

Dana Kobilinsky, The Wildlife Society, January 17, 2023

 

Can Killing One Species of Owl Help Save Another?

Sarah Kuta, Smithsonian Magazine, January 10, 2024

 

Bird of the Month: The “Sparred” Owl

Elise Brosnan, Northern Virginia Bird Alliance, May 1, 2019

 

Owl Vs. Owl

Alison Harford, Sierra Club Magazine, May 14, 2024

 

For US Fish & Wildlife Service “Management” Means Killing

Conservation Sense & Nonsense (blog), January 1, 2024

 

There Will Be Blood

Warren Cornwall, Anthropocene Magazine, 2024

 

Bringing Ethics to Wild Lives: Shaping Public Policy for Barred and Northern Spotted Owls

William Lynn, Society & Animals Issue 26, 2018

 

Killing one owl to save another

Michelle Nijhuis, High Country News, May 10, 2024

 

The Owls that Came from Away

Jude Isabella, Hakai Magazine, July 2, 2024

 

 

 

In Defense of Nature: Why Barred Owls Should Not Be Killed to “Save” Spotted Owls

The All About Owls News Page

Archives

1 Comment

  1. Caroline Babinski on December 3, 2025 at 10:24 am

    why can’t all the feral hogs be killed by supposedly marksman which is causing massive damage to crops, killing domestic sheep, cattle goats, go kill them not these precious birds? This just sick , why are governments allowed to kill all kinds of wildlife like the wolves?

Leave a Comment